<https://twitter.com/_julesh_/status/1166709683815...
# linking-together
g
https://twitter.com/_julesh_/status/1166709683815624705?s=21 brexit inspired by bret victor? don’t even know what emojis to attach to this but i know it deserves a lot of them
😳 6
w
d
That's a misleading clickbait headline. Author cites Bret Victor's ideas on using tech to improve decision making. Then says "It is relevant to Brexit and anybody thinking ‘how on earth do we escape this nightmare’ but 1) these ideas are not at all dependent on whether you support or oppose Brexit, about which reasonable people disagree, and 2) they are generally applicable to how to improve decision-making"
a
I personally know the guy. He's pretty "random". Not meant that as an offense, more like a "take it with a /truck/ of salt".
i
Brexit is very interesting. It's one of the few cases I'm aware of where both the hard left and hard right are generally in favor of one position (leave), but the people in the center are generally in favor of another (remain).
💡 1
This article is very long. If anyone reads it, I'd love a summary of the main points.
d
Well, meanwhile, here's a summary of your last message, @Ivan Reese: "TL;DR" 😄
🍰 2
g
it’s more of a rant than an article. i read it all—boils down to “the elites running society make bad decisions and use barely any technology or data to help them make those decisions. we could do a lot better if we empowered people like Bret to do research into new forms of media and thinking and used that to better inform an alternative political process”
“The same story repeats: genuinely new ideas that could create huge value always seem so odd that almost all people in almost all organisations cannot see new possibilities. If this is true in Silicon Valley, how much more true is it in Whitehall or Washington… If one were setting up a new party in Britain, one could incorporate some of these ideas. This would of course also require recruiting very different types of people to the norm in politics. The closed nature of Westminster/Whitehall combined with first-past-the-post means it is very hard to solve the coordination problem of how to break into this system with a new way of doing things. Even those interested in principle don’t want to commit to a 10-year (?) project that might get them blasted on the front pages. Vote Leave hacked the referendum but such opportunities are much rarer than VC-funded ‘unicorns’. On the other hand, arguably what is happening now is a once in 50 or 100 year crisis and such crises also are the waves that can be ridden to change things normally unchangeable.”
i
At the risk of being absurdly reductive: this sounds like another case of.. a technologist looking at a different industry / domain / culture and saying, "I'm really good at decomposing and solving problems, so you should let me decompose and solve your problems" without really bothering to understand those problems beyond a superficial level. (Yes, the irony of me saying this is not lost on me.)
s
Dommining Cummins also names his opeds after Lenin pamflets ...
@Ivan Reese have you read/seen "Seeing like a state"?
👍 1
k
Actually there's a larger irony in your comment, @Ivan Reese: in this case it's not the technologist (Bret Victor) saying that! It's somebody else (not sure how to pigeonhole the guy) saying, "let the technologist decompose and solve our problems."
i
Good point.
d
I have this idea that blame works like electricity and you can imagine flows of small particles of blame. Given “”let the technologist decompose and solve our problems” we might be observing a “lightening conductor”… ?
🤓 1
s
Is Cummings a technologist? Or is he a technologist who has spend an enormous amount of time navigating political systems successfully? The combination of these two very different skillsets fascinates and worries me at the same time.
j
d
Honestly you have to wonder if Cummings wants to be parodied. Why would the second most powerful man in the UK dress like an evil gnome? Can’t he afford a suit? and he could get some deportment and speech lessons? It’s like he’s trying very hard to look like a sinister weirdo…?
s
He's the second most powerful person in the country. If not the most. He's isn't funny, he is extremely dangerous
g
i think there are pretty obvious parallels with steve bannon