5 Years There Will Be No Phones - No Apps, No Oper...
# thinking-together
c
5 Years There Will Be No Phones - No Apps, No Operating Systems https://www.youtube.com/shorts/B0cmlitxne0 Musk has made a lot of predictions and some of them did came to in a way. How do you feel about this, of course Joe Rogan asks about how everything will go through the AI. Aside from technical aspects - what about the social and surveillance implications? How do you feel about this?
☢️ 4
i
A) musk and rogan are toxic and i refuse to give them any time or attention, and i don't like seeing them here. B) I like gruber's recent refutations of this idea, eg: AI Is Technology, Not a Product
💯 10
c
maybe let me rephrase: if we have consumerism now, how will this affect people who are now consumers ? would you see consumers or rather today's „tech people(programmers ?)“ see pushing against this ? or not or something entirely different ?
j
Not sure why we wouldn't want to discuss the ideas of a prominent technologist like Elon here. I know a lot of people disagree with his politics, but it's hard to discuss technology without mentioning him. What Elon says in that clip does seem to be a likely outcome if you take the bitter lesson to its conclusion. As for consumerism if Elons optimistic predictions come to pass we will probably think of a lot of goods similarly to how we think of air today. The bigger question I think is how it will affect producers. If we hit post-scarcity will some of us still need to find a purpose, and what will it be?
🙏 1
i
It's quite easy to discuss technology without mentioning him. This is the first conversation I've had about him and/or his tech in... a month? Longer? And his politics are valid grounds to ignore anything he says and that he even exists. There is no shortage of other smarter, kinder, more interesting people whose work deserves our time and attention.
❤️ 9
(FWIW, I'm refusing to watch the clip on principle. I'll now duck out of this conversation.)
3
c
I can understand you reservations ivan, his transhumanist tendencies feel also very frightening to me. But he is also the one pushing very hard with xAI and optimus to make it happen.
i
It's his transphobia, his nazi sympathy, his alliance with Trump, his disregard for democracy and the public good, and other such inexcusable acts that give me reservations. None of that is transhumanism, he's merely a bad person.
👍 5
💯 10
j
Essentially every person on Earth right now is talking about AI, including smart and thoughtful people who are not Nazis, so I think we have the luxury of not listening to the ones who are Nazis.
🤍 5
🫴🏼 1
w
I know some real Musk fans: people who've worked with him and like it. However, he is the kind of person who does not know the limits of his competency, so it's hard to know whether a given comment is worth paying attention to. And Rogan as interviewer is the not the least bit critical. So that should help explain why even a minute long quote like this would not be deemed worthy of attention. On to the substance though: I'm really interested in the idea of AI used for bespoke interfaces. And one thing I've learned is that you want a means by which a one-off answer/process that the AI thought hard to give becomes automated. codified. and standardized. Not for efficiency sake, but for predictability. You want to know that the view is a "simple," reproducible function of the underlying data.
2
k
@Jake Brownson
If we hit post-scarcity
We won't. That's the other problem with people like Elon Musk (in addition to being a bad person): hubris. If you listen to anyone who has made a serious effort to understand stocks and flows of resources in our universe, you will find out that this dream of post-scarcity will never come true, unless there are very serious and resource-relevant holes in our understanding of physics. Well, there is one exception: a drastic reduction of the human population of this planet. The survivors can enjoy post-scarcity for a while. At a poverty level, but still.
1
c
In my other discussion group I put up some background in about musk... how he was influenced "None of that is transhumanism, he's merely a bad person." I think thats a bit superficial, even if I share now a bit about musk, its not per se about him but about Silicon valleys narrative for the future Trans- Posthumanism
Musks Depressing Philosophers • #tags: #elon_musk #philosophy #nietzsche • • EM: "We happened to have some books by Nietzsche and Schopenhauer in the house, which you should not read at age 14" • • EM: "I guess when I was around 12 or 15…I had an existential crisis, and I was reading various books on trying to figure out the meaning of life and what does it all mean? It all seemed quite meaningless and then we happened to have some books by Nietzsche and Schopenhauer in the house, which you should not read at age 14 (laughter). It is bad, it’s really negative. So then I read Hitchhikers Guide to the Galaxy which is quite positive I think and it highlighted an important point which is that a lot of times the question is harder than the answer. And if you can properly phrase the question, then the answer is the easy part. So, to the degree that we can better understand the universe, then we can better know what questions to ask. Then whatever the question is that most approximates: what’s the meaning of life? That’s the question we can ultimately get closer to understanding. And so I thought to the degree that we can expand the scope and scale of consciousness and knowledge, then that would be a good thing." Source: https://www.freshdialogues.com/2013/02/07/transcript-of-elon-musk-interview-with-alison-van-diggelen-iron-man-growing-up-in-south-africa/
How did Capitalism and his family relationships influence him?
Very influential was his Marriage with Justin Musk ( and the death of their first son)
At this point one can see how money got into the mind of elon as a invasive force, how his psychology was twisted to - create the future he imagined, by all means necessary -
The Cook and the Chef: Musk’s Secret Sauce • #tags: #elon_musk #waitbutwhy #article #society #frame #narrative • • https://waitbutwhy.com/2015/11/the-cook-and-the-chef-musks-secret-sauce.html • • brain as a computer and many other sloppy analogies • it seems at least at that time tim urban was kind of riding on the "new atheists" wave of the culture wars, has it informed his identity • the feedback loop patterns are interesting, but in the whole article he doesn't mention psychology? • quoting seth godin, I am reminded of jordan halls remark on him • musks "reasoning from first principles" its a frame of thought a view on the world see heideggers - aleteiha • but somehow it also could be look at everything with a fresh perspective - sadhguru • also it feels very strongly like the "*naive progress story*" daniel schmachtenberger mentions • "musk software" and grand theft life
When Musk hired Tim urban to write about his goals and aspirations in life that was already a bigger plan on expanding his mindset to a bigger audience, to create appeal for....
Neuralink and the Brain’s Magical Futurehttps://waitbutwhy.com/2017/04/neuralink.html • in this article the sci fci Nexus by Ramez Naam is Mention and in there are the clear descriptions of trans- and post humanism
Is it inevitable that Brain Interfaces exist like in the Nexus books? Of course all my writing here is also a check on how close you feel the butlerian Jihad is.
i
Yeah, no. None of this discussion of Musk as a person is worth our time or attention. Please take it elsewhere. If you want to talk about ideas that he holds that are relevant to our community, fine, but do it without talking about him.
(Meta: If you feel like I'm being unfair or am somehow missing the point by shutting down this discussion, I'd be happy to talk more about that, either here or in #CEXED56UR or via DMs.)
c
A one more thing that I wanted to share re musk(Silicon Valley) mind set

https://youtu.be/RGSQWjoC9v0?is=10MFM5wo_9U3BPy1

m
ah, the "professor"
c
i di not care if he is a professor
But his : Civilization, series did contain some interesting perspectives on what kind of patterns influence history.
did you see his episode on stalin or the last on the collapsing uS?
m
oh, many ideas he talks about can be of several degrees of truth, the dispersal factor is what worries me. specially with certain conspiracy theories and more mystical shit
c
Yes social media is breaking reality apart. In some good and many bad ways